Cart

Your cart is currently empty.

Continue shopping

Egg Cream and More

What do you love about egg creams? Share your memories, favorite recipes, or other yummy seltzer concoctions (cherry lime rickey, etc.).

Back to the blog title

comments

The last time I had an egg cream was TODAY at the Brooklyn Seltzer Museum!!! I had a vanilla and a strawberry one and they were delicious. Now I want to try all the other flavors that exist.
Yiyi Jun 9, 2025
Lived on Coffee Street in Red Hook, early 1980's, the 'Seltzer Man' would come down our cobblestone street and sell us wooden cases of the blue bottles with the spray spouts with Fox's U-Bet Chocolate Syrup. Simply THE BEST! I don't think I've had an eggcream that delicious ever again.
Deb T May 2, 2025
Interesting learning about the history and making of seltzer water!
Cyn May 2, 2025
My parents owned a candy store on Clinton Street in the Lower Eastside in the late 20s and early 30s. My mother told me that when people wanted a glass of seltzer, they would ask for a two-cent plain. Some customers would ask for a very sweet egg cream and drink about half and then say it was too sweet and request more seltzer to be added. This gave them an additional half of a glass for the price of one egg cream. Growing up in the 40s and living in a Brooklyn apartment on the first floor, then referred to as the floor above the ground floor, my brother and I would go out on our fire escape and yell "hot scramble" and throw down comic books we no longer wanted. Other kids would go to where the comic books were thrown and we would squirt them with seltzer bottles.
Harvey May 2, 2025
I was told the secret of making a good egg cream was to use very cold milk.
Harvey May 2, 2025

Post comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.